>

Cotton Mattress vs. Coir Mattress

Updated by

Cotton mattress or coir mattress? Which one to choose? Most of us get confused when choosing between them. We all want to choose the best bed mattress that is just perfect for us. But, how do we do that?

This article answers all your questions. We will compare both the products and try to understand which type of mattress is better. In the end, the sleeper should feel comfortable and enjoy an uninterrupted good night’s sleep.

Let us explore the various parameters of the cotton and coir mattresses. This will help us analyze which mattress is better and how you can get benefitted from them.

Let us get into the discussion.

What is Cotton Mattress?

As the name says, these mattresses have a cotton filling. We all know that cotton mattresses have been in use for centuries and are a popular option for many Asian countries, especially Indians.

If we talk about construction, these mattresses have several layers of cotton fibres added in a traditional way. The outer layer of the mattress typically consists of waterproof or thick fabric. Cotton mattresses are popular for their softness and great comfort.

Above all, cotton mattresses are the cheapest mattresses of all. India, being the largest producer of cotton, uses pure cotton to stuff inside these mattresses. And the best part, these are available in all sizes for the different needs of the customers. Apart from the king, queen, twin, and double sizes, people often get them customized as per their requirements.

What are the Advantages and Disadvantages of Cotton Mattresses?

Although the cotton mattresses served well in the past, with the advent of modern mattresses there seems to be a tough competition between the duo. Let us understand the benefits and limitations of using a cotton mattress.

Advantages

  • Cotton mattresses are very soft and offer great comfort levels.
  • They are available in all sizes, including the customized options.
  • Cotton mattresses provide proper ventilation.
  • These mattresses are highly breathable and promote good air circulation.
  • They do not trap the body heat.
  • Cotton mattresses are very cheaper when compared to other types of mattresses.
  • They have fewer replacement costs.
  • The cotton mattresses are environmental-friendly.
  • Cotton mattresses are durable and long-lasting.
  • The cotton mattresses guarantee low motion transfer.
  • Since cotton is a natural material, these mattresses keep allergens away from you.

Disadvantages

  • Cotton mattresses are prone to bed bugs and dust mites.
  • Upon usage, these mattresses sag and become uneven.
  • These mattresses are not fire-proof and are susceptible to fire hazards.
  • Over time, the cotton mattresses become hard and cause pains in the pressure points.
  • The cotton mattresses lose their shape after few years.
  • These mattresses are non-responsive, and hence they do not provide appropriate support to the spine.
  • These mattresses are not ideal for back pain and may aggravate it.
  • Cotton mattresses require high maintenance.

What is Coir Mattress?

As the name suggests, these mattresses have layers of coir obtained from the coconut husk. The coir mattresses have been in use for ages. They are a popular option for many because of their eco-friendly nature.

Let us talk about the construction. These mattresses come surrounded with coir fibre on top and bottom layers. The middle layer consists of high-density foam. The coir on both sides comes covered with a cotton insulated layer to give the final texture to the mattress. The outer layer of the mattress is of premium quality fabric that provides an attractive look.

The coir mattresses are basically of two types – Hybrid coir mattress and Rubberized coir mattress.

The hybrid mattresses have coir filling, which comes covered by adjustable foam layers. These mattresses provide proper ventilation and help in improving rest.

The rubberized coir mattresses are the ones that come with a mix of latex foam and coir. That means this foam covers the coir to offer great comfort. This mattress helps in offering orthopaedic benefits to the sleeper.

Even the coir mattresses are available in king, queen, single and double sizes.

What are the Advantages and Disadvantages of Coir Mattresses?

The coir mattresses also have advantages and disadvantages. Let us take a look at what they are:

Advantages

  • The coir mattresses offer great health benefits.
  • They are available in all sizes, like the king, queen, single and double sizes.
  • The coir mattresses have a hygroscopic quality that helps in absorbing moisture and guaranteeing comfortable sleep.
  • These mattresses provide proper ventilation.
  • These mattresses promote cool sleep during summers.
  • The coir mattresses provide appropriate support to the spine.
  • These mattresses are ideal for people with allergies.
  • The coir mattresses are environmental-friendly.
  • They are fire-proof and have high resistance to fire.
  • The coir mattresses are very affordable when compared to memory foam and latex mattresses.
  • These mattresses are ideal for young children whose bones are in the developing stage and the elderly, who need additional support.
  • Since these mattresses contain natural materials, they are safe and harmless.
  • They do not require any maintenance.
  • These mattresses are not prone to bed bugs and dust mites.

Disadvantages

  • The coir mattresses can be a little firm to sleep upon. These are medium-firm mattresses.
  • Upon usage, these mattresses sag and become uneven.
  • These mattresses are harder than the spring and foam mattresses.
  • Since the material used to manufacture a coir mattress is not soft, sleeping on them can cause pains in the pressure points.
  • They are bad conductors of heat.
  • The coir mattresses lose their shape after few years and cannot retain the shape.
  • These mattresses are less durable when compared to spring and foam mattresses.
  • They are not ideal for those who love to sleep on a very soft surface.

What Are The Differences Between Cotton And Coir Mattresses?

Cotton Mattress vs. Coir Mattress

Here is a table distinguishing the characteristic features of both cotton and coir mattresses. This will help you understand which product is the better one.

Characteristic FeatureCotton MattressCoir Mattress
ComfortIt offers great comfort levels.It is less comfortable.
TextureVery soft.Medium-firm mattress.
Perfect VentilationCotton mattresses provide proper ventilation.Coir mattresses provide proper ventilation.
Moisture-Absorbing AbilityYesYes
BreathabilityYesYes
Health BenefitsNoYes
Back Pain ProblemsThese mattresses are not ideal for back pain and may aggravate it.The coir mattresses provide appropriate support to the spine.
HypoallergenicYesYes
Motion TransferLow motion transferZero motion transfer
Environmental-FriendlyYesYes
Fire ResistantA cotton mattress is not fire-resistant.A cotton mattress is fire-resistant.
Water ResistantA cotton mattress is not water-resistant.A cotton mattress is water-resistant.
Free From Dust MitesNoYes
DurabilityHighly durable and long-lasting than the coir mattresses.Less durable when compared to a cotton mattress.
AffordabilityVery cheaperAffordable
MaintenanceRequires high maintenanceRequires low maintenance
AvailabilityAvailable in all sizes, including customized options.Available in all sizes.

Let us analyze each parameter in detail to decide which type to choose. We will have the winner in each category for an easy understanding and decision-making process.

1) Comfort     

Let us start with comfort. We all need and look for comfortability when sleeping, and it is a crucial parameter. When it comes to cotton mattresses, they are known for offering great comfort levels.

On the other hand, the coir mattresses are less comfortable because of their firmness. As a result, people might toss and turn on the beds and do not enjoy a comfortable sleep.

Winner: A cotton mattress stands the clear winner in this segment.

2) Texture      

The texture is yet another determining factor in choosing a mattress. If you consider the texture of the cotton mattress, it is very soft. The material infused in the cotton mattress gives it a soft and smooth texture.

Coming to the coir mattresses, they are not soft. In fact, they are medium-firm mattresses. They are harder than most mattress types.

Winner: Again, a cotton mattress stands as the clear winner in this segment.

3) Perfect Ventilation

The cotton mattresses have good air circulation and provide proper ventilation.

The coir mattresses provide proper ventilation, allowing good circulation of air.

Winner: Both cotton and coir mattresses get equal points here.

4) Moisture-absorbing Ability         

Let us talk about the moisture absorbing ability. A cotton mattress is capable of absorbing moisture.

Similar to the cotton mattress, even a coir mattress has good moisture absorbing ability.

Winner: Here, the score is a tie as both cotton and coir mattresses tend to have an equal inclination.

5) Breathability

Because of the good air circulation and ventilation, both cotton and coir mattresses are breathable.

Winner: Again, both cotton and coir mattresses get equal points here.

6) Health Benefits

We often look for health benefits that a mattress provides. If we have this as a point of consideration, there are no health benefits, as such, from the cotton mattress.

Unlike the above, a coir mattress offers great health benefits.

Winner: Needless to say, a coir mattress stands the clear winner in this aspect.

7) Back Pain Problems          

A mattress should be able to support the spine properly, so as, to alleviate back pain problems, if any. Unfortunately, a cotton mattress fails in this part as it cannot provide the required support to the spine. Instead, it may aggravate the back pain problems of the sleepers.

Contrary to the cotton mattress, a coir mattress provides appropriate support to the spine. Thereby, it helps in alleviating back pain.

Winner: Undoubtedly, a coir mattress is a winner.

8) Hypoallergenic

We all know that cotton is a natural material. Hence, these mattresses keep allergens away from you.

Even the coir mattresses do not contain anything like dust in them. Hence, they are ideal for those with dust allergies.

Winner: Again, both cotton and coir mattresses get equal points here.

9) Motion Transfer

If you have a partner who tosses and turns over the bed frequently, it might disturb your sleep. Hence, you need a mattress that does not bother your sleep by allowing the motion transfer. A cotton mattress allows low motion transfer.

Coming to the coir mattress, it allows zero motion transfer on the bed.

Winner: Again, a coir mattress is a winner.

10) Environmental-Friendly

Since both cotton and coir mattresses are made from natural materials, they are eco-friendly.

Winner: Both cotton and coir mattresses seem to have an equal edge here.

11) Fire Resistant

We all know about the nature of cotton material. They have no resistance to fire and are prone to fire hazards in case of an accident. The cotton mattresses are not fire-proof, and hence you cannot use heaters or blowers near them.

As opposed to the above, coir mattresses have resistance to fire. They remain unharmed and safe when compared to other types of mattresses.

Winner: A coir mattress leads the race in this aspect.

12) Water Resistant  

During incidents like getting drained with water or sweat, or any other drinks, the mattresses should be capable of drying out quickly. A cotton mattress is the complete opposite in this aspect. It does not dry quickly when it becomes wet. As a result, there are chances of bacterial growth because of the left-over moisture.

Unlike the cotton mattress, a coir mattress dries out quickly after getting wet.

Winner: Again, a coir mattress takes the lead in this comparison.

13) Free From Dust Mites     

A cotton mattress is not free from dust mites and bed bugs. In fact, it is prone to them.

Unlike cotton mattresses, coir mattresses are not prone to bed bugs and dust mites.

Winner: It looks like a coir mattress is running ahead in this competition.

14) Durability

Now, durability is one of the most crucial factors for determining whether you can purchase this mattress or not. This is something we do not prefer to overlook. If you consider the durability factor, a cotton mattress is highly durable and long-lasting than the coir mattresses.

A coir mattress is not that durable and has a lifespan of approximately five years. These days, manufacturers are mixing latex material with the coir. These mattresses can last a long time, though.

Winner: It looks like a cotton mattress has a slight edge in this parameter.

15) Affordability

Price is yet another deciding factor. If you consider the cost at which a cotton mattress is available you would be in awe. Yes, they are very cheap. They usually come in the price range of Rs. 1,500 to Rs. 1000.

Coming to the coir mattresses, they are affordable. They fall under the price range of Rs. 20,000 and Rs. 50,000.

Winner: Undoubtedly, a coir mattress is a winner.

16) Maintenance

Let us come to the maintenance part. A cotton mattress requires high maintenance, like drying them under the sun periodically.

Whereas, a coir mattress requires low maintenance.

Winner: A coir mattress is a winner here.

17) Availability

Both cotton and coir mattresses are available in all sizes. However, a cotton mattress comes in customized options, as well.

Winner: A cotton mattress has a slight inclination here.

FAQs

Is cotton mattress or coir ideal for relief from back pain? 

When it comes to back pain, it is advisable to go for a medium-firm mattress. Since coir has medium firmness, it provides additional support to your spine. Therefore, it might help in relieving the pain and tension in the pressure points.

Conclusion

To conclude, both cotton and coir mattresses have their own benefits and limitations. What mattress to choose is again dependent on the individual preferences and requirements. His article provided you with all the information that you need to know about both types. Now that you have a clear understanding and knowledge of the same, choosing a perfect mattress would not be a tough task for you. Let us know your choice by posting your answers in the comments.

Write to us in the comments section below if you find this article helpful and informative. Let us know if you have any questions or need more information on the same. Feel free to add your inputs to this write-up, and let us know if we missed out on any points.

Your feedback is important to us, and we would love to hear and learn from you.

Stay healthy and stay safe!!!

Related Posts:

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *