Cotton Mattress vs. Coir Mattress

Updated by

“Choose the Comfortable Mattress You Deserve to Experience Quality Sleep”

Coir Mattress or Cotton Mattress – which one is the ideal option? This is the most common dilemma faced by everyone while purchasing a mattress.

The right one among them depends on individual needs. Apart from comfort, there are several other factors as well to consider while analyzing between these two options.

In this article, we have provided all the information including benefits and drawbacks of each variant. Read it thoroughly to determine which one is suitable for your needs.

What is Cotton Mattress?

Cotton is one of the traditional ways to stuff up a mattress. Though there are several mattresses with different material construction, some people particularly Asian and Indians still prefer this option.

In these mattresses, several layers of cotton fibers are added. The outer layer is mostly made from waterproof or thick fabric. Some manufacturers use synthetic fibers instead of natural cotton fibers. But it is not desirable option for people dealing with skin and respiratory allergies.

As Indian is one of the largest producers of cotton, these mattresses are available at affordable price range. They are available in king, queen, twin and double sizes. Some people even customize them as per their requirements.

What is Coir Mattress?

In these mattresses, the primary filling material is coir or fibers derived from coconut husk. Premium quality fabric is used as outer layers to cover them up and provide an attractive look. They are also called as hybrid mattresses.

Rubberized coir mattresses are also available, in which a latex foam layer is provided on top of coir to provide more comfort and softer option. Coir mattresses are available in all sizes including queen, king, single and double.

Cotton Vs Coir – Which One to Choose?

To provide a brief overview, we have presented the synopsis in the below table.

Sleeping PositionsBack and tummyAll
Back Pain ProblemsNoYes
Fire ResistantNoYes
Moisture AbsorptionYesNo

Coir or Cotton – Which One to Choose Among Them?

There are several advantages of cotton mattress. We have provided some of them below for your reference.

Durability –

Durability and strength are the first features we can think of when it comes to cotton mattress. Unlike other materials, cotton doesn’t disintegrate when wet. You can expect it to run for long and remain intact for over ten years. Even if the cotton starts breaking or gets displaced, you can get the mattress refilled and use it again.

Coir mattresses are more prone to sagging. Over a certain period of time, their surface becomes uneven. So, when you sleep on uneven mattress, the spine doesn’t get properly aligned which can lead to back pain. Unlike cotton, coir mattresses cannot be recycled by adding additional amount of coir. Once, it becomes displaced and uneven you have to purchase a new one.

Firmness –

When it comes to firmness, coir is firmer than cotton. In the initial days, cotton may feel firm but as the times goes, they tend to become soft. However, coir doesn’t get soft. Its firmness stays for a longer time.

Resistance –

Among both these types of mattresses, coir mattress is more water resistant while cotton is not.

If a coir mattress gets wet, it will dry out pretty quickly. However, if a cotton mattress gets wet, it takes a lot of time to get dry. If any moisture is left out, it can attract bacterial growth.

If you like keeping heaters or blowers on your bed during winters, coir mattresses can be your ideal mattress. It’s because coir mattresses are fire-resistant. But cotton is an inflammable material. So, you never use heaters or blowers near cotton mattresses.

Cotton can easily get affected by dust mites, while coir is resistant to insects.

Hypoallergenic –

Both cotton and coir are natural fibers so they are hypoallergenic and eco-friendly. Coir comes with anti-dust qualities. So, if you’re someone with allergies, this mattress won’t affect you negatively. With cotton mattresses, there is high chance of dust accumulation within the fibers. So, you have to dust it regularly. People with dust-allergies may find it a bit uncomfortable.

Breathability –

Both cotton and coir mattresses are breathable and promote proper air circulation. It allows air to circulate through it. Therefore, it’s ideal if your area experiences hot weather.

Motion Transfer –

If you have a partner who tosses during the night, you should avoid coir mattresses. The stiffness of the coir fibers makes them a little bouncy. So, there is a chance of feeling the wave or tossing when your partners turns or make a move while sleeping.  But this is not the case with cotton mattresses. Cotton fibers don’t bounce, you will not feel the disturbance and sleep comfortably.

Moisture Absorption –

Apart from being breathable, cotton mattresses come with a natural wicking property. Cotton has the ability to absorb sweat from the user’s body leaving behind a cool and dry surface.

As you won’t feel the moisture on the bed or on your body, you will experience quality sleep. The cotton mattress will become as good as new if you put it in the sun for a few hours. So, if you’re someone who lives in a hot and humid climate, then cotton mattress can do wonders for you.

Coir fibers are not capable of absorbing sweat or moisture, so you may feel hot and sweaty. So, it is not an ideal option for people who live in tropical or hot climatic localities.

Sleeping Comfort –

The coconut husk gives it a holding quality and makes it feel quite stiff. These features support the body evenly from all sides and provide a better sleeping experience. They are perfect for people who deal with body pains or back pain.

When it comes to cotton mattresses, they are soft, cushiony and fluffy which makes them perfect for people who want more comfortable space to sleep. However, it cannot provide enough support to your spine or shoulder. So, it may not be a compatible option for people with back issues.

Price –

India is one of the largest manufacturers of cotton and coir. So, you can get good quality cotton and coir mattresses. When both these options are compared, coir is more expensive than cotton. Cotton mattresses are available around Rs. 1500 to Rs. 10000. While coir mattresses are available at Rs. 20000 to Rs. 50000. The price variation depends on the size and other factors.

Some Frequently Asked Questions:

1. Which mattress is suitable for relieving back pain – coir or cotton?

When it comes to health issues like back pain, it better to go for a mattress with medium firmness. It is better to go for a coir mattress as it supports your spine properly and its firmness relieves tension in the pressure points. So, you can experience a peaceful sleep.

Few Words Before Wrapping Up…

Both cotton and coir mattresses have their own advantages and disadvantage. There is no definitive answer for the question – which one is the best among them. Every individual has their own priorities when it comes to sleeping requirements.

For people whose priority is comfort or who sweat a lot during sleep, we recommend going for cotton mattress.

For people who want support to spine, have back pain issues or allergies, we recommend going for coir mattresses.

We hope the information provided in this article has helped to clarify your doubts. For more such insights, follow us. If you have any questions, write to us in the comment section. We shall reply at the earliest convenient time.

Related Posts:

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *